IADVL
Indexed with PubMed and Science Citation Index (E) 
 
Users online: 1681 
     Home | Feedback | Login 
About Current Issue Archive Ahead of print Search Instructions Online Submission Subscribe What's New Contact  
  Navigate here 
  Search
 
   Next article
   Previous article 
   Table of Contents
  
 Resource links
   Similar in PUBMED
    Search Pubmed for
    Search in Google Scholar for
  Related articles
   Article in PDF (123 KB)
   Citation Manager
   Access Statistics
   Reader Comments
   Email Alert *
   Add to My List *
* Registration required (free)  

 
  In this article
   Abstract
   Introduction
   Materials and me...
   Results
   Conclusion
   Discussion
   References
   Article Tables

 Article Access Statistics
    Viewed13037    
    Printed316    
    Emailed16    
    PDF Downloaded754    
    Comments [Add]    
    Cited by others 16    

Recommend this journal

 


 
STUDIES
Year : 2005  |  Volume : 71  |  Issue : 4  |  Page : 262-266

An open randomized comparative study of oral itraconazole pulse and terbinafine pulse in the treatment of onychomycosis


1 Department of Dermatology and Venereology, S.C.B.Medical College, Cuttack, Orissa, India
2 Department of Microbiology, S.C.B.Medical College, Cuttack, Orissa, India
3 Department of Community Medicine, S.C.B.Medical College, Cuttack, Orissa, India

Correspondence Address:
Minati Mishra
698, Nayapalli, (Behind Kasturba Women's College), Bhubaneswar-12, Orissa
India
Login to access the Email id

Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None


DOI: 10.4103/0378-6323.16619

Rights and Permissions

  Abstract 

BACKGROUND: Onychomycosis is a recalcitrant disease of the nails caused by dermatophytes, yeasts, and molds. AIMS: To compare the clinical efficacy of oral itraconazole pulse therapy and oral terbinafine pulse therapy in onychomycosis. METHODS: A randomized single-blind clinical comparative study was undertaken on 120 patients of onychomycosis during the period March 1999-February 2002. Sixty patients were randomly assigned to receive oral itraconazole 100 mg, two capsules twice daily for seven days a month and the other group of sixty patients received oral terbinafine 250 mg, one tablet twice daily for seven days every month. Four such monthly pulses were administered for each drug. The patients were evaluated at 4-weekly intervals till sixteen weeks and then at 24, 36 and 48 weeks. RESULTS: We observed a clinical cure rate of 82% and mycological cure rate of 90% in the group of patients treated with itraconazole while the group with terbinafine showed clinical and mycological cure rates of 79% and 87% respectively. This difference was not statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: Both oral itraconazole and terbinafine are effective in the treatment of onychomycosis when administered in the pulse dosage form. Terbinafine is more cost effective while itraconazole has a broader spectrum of antimycotic activity.


Keywords: Onychomycosis, Dermatophytes, Yeasts, Mould, Pulse


How to cite this article:
Mishra M, Panda P, Tripathy S, Sengupta S, Mishra K. An open randomized comparative study of oral itraconazole pulse and terbinafine pulse in the treatment of onychomycosis. Indian J Dermatol Venereol Leprol 2005;71:262-6

How to cite this URL:
Mishra M, Panda P, Tripathy S, Sengupta S, Mishra K. An open randomized comparative study of oral itraconazole pulse and terbinafine pulse in the treatment of onychomycosis. Indian J Dermatol Venereol Leprol [serial online] 2005 [cited 2019 Aug 19];71:262-6. Available from: http://www.ijdvl.com/text.asp?2005/71/4/262/16619



  Introduction Top


Onychomycosis is a chronic infection of the nail predominantly caused by anthropophilic dermatophytes and, to a lesser extent, by yeasts ( Candida spp.), and non-dermatophyte molds. It represents 30% of all mycotic infections of the skin.[1],[2] Although onychomycosis is not life threatening, the psychosocial and emotional effects due to the disease can be profound and it can have a significant negative impact on the quality of life of those affected.[3],[4] Several clinical types of onychomycosis have been recognized, i.e. distal and lateral subungual onychomycosis (DSLO), white superficial onychomycosis (WSO), proximal subungual onychomycosis (PSO), endonyx onychomycosis, and candidal onychomycosis. Total dystrophic onychomycosis refers to the most advanced form affecting the entire nail plate. [5],[6],[7]

The treatment of onychomycosis is far from satisfactory due to several factors like poor cure rate of conventional antifungals, longer duration of therapy, high cost of therapy and the inherent slow growth of the nail plate requiring a longer time (about one year) to see observable effects of successful treatment.[8] However, the advent of itraconazole and terbinafine has revolutionized the therapy of onychomycosis because these drugs have high clinical and mycological cure rates by virtue of their ability to easily penetrate into the nail apparatus and persist there for many months after stopping therapy. Their effectiveness in the treatment of onychomycosis is now well-established.[9],[10],[11],[12],[13],[14],[15],[16],[17],[18] A major limitation to their widespread use is their high cost and consequently different therapeutic schedules have been used to minimize the cost without affecting the efficacy. The use of pulse therapy instead of daily administration is one such innovation that has shown encouraging results in the case of itraconazole. Terbinafine is conventionally given in daily doses for 6-12 weeks. Since it also persists in the nail apparatus for long durations even after stopping therapy, pulse therapy is a viable option as shown by different studies.[13] Our study compares the clinical efficacy of itraconazole pulse therapy with terbinafine pulse therapy in the treatment of onychomycosis.


  Materials and methods Top


This randomized, single-blind, longitudinal, clinical comparative study was undertaken in the Department of Skin and Venereal Diseases, S. C. B. Medical College, Cuttack, in collaboration with the Department of Microbiology, during the period March 1999-February 2002.

All patients presenting to the dermatology O.P.D. with clinical features of fingernail or toenail onychomycosis (e.g. discoloration, thinning, crumbling or destruction of the nail plate; subungual debris; or onycholysis) were subjected to direct microscopical examination of nail material under potassium hydroxide (KOH) examination and culture in Sabouraud's Dextrose agar (SDA). Patients with nail abnormalities due to associated skin disease or any systemic diseases like psoriasis, lichen planus, contact dermatitis, congenital nail dystrophy, malnutrition, iron deficiency, etc. were excluded from the study. We came across 645 patents clinically suggestive of onychomycosis during the period of two years. The patients were clearly explained about the nature of the study and a written consent was taken for their participation in the study. A baseline liver function test was done in all of them and those with hepatic dysfunction in the form of jaundice and/or elevated hepatic enzymes more than twice the normal values were excluded from the study. Other criteria for exclusion were pregnancy, lactation, concomitant therapy with drugs having a possible interaction with itraconazole, age<15 years or >60 years, and mycologically negative cases (both negative for KOH examination and culture on Sabouraud's dextrose agar (SDA)). A total of 120 patients satisfied the above criteria and agreed to participate in the study. They were in the 15-60 year age group (72 males and 48 females) and were recruited into the study.

All patients were assigned individual identification numbers and were divided randomly and equally into two groups (A and B) using a table of random numbers. Thus, two groups of 60 patients each with 36 men and 24 women in the age group 15-60 were created. Group A received oral itraconazole 200 mg (two capsules of Cap. Sporanoxγ 100 mg) twice daily for seven consecutive days every month while Group B received oral terbinafine 250 mg {Tab. Sebifinγ 250mg} twice daily for seven consecutive days every month. The total duration of treatment for both groups was 4 months. The cost of therapy was borne by the patients. The drugs were bought by the physician and dispensed to the patients in unmarked packets containing the entire dosage for seven days every month for four months.

The patients were evaluated at the start of the therapy and thereafter at 4-week (or monthly) intervals for 4 months, followed by evaluation at weeks 24, 36, and 48. During these visits, they were assessed for growth of a normal and healthy appearing nail plate and asked for any adverse effects of the drugs. In addition, microscopic examination of nail material under KOH examination and culture of nail material in SDA was done at 16 weeks and 48 weeks. A liver function test was done twice for all patients at 6-month intervals from the start of therapy.

Clinical cure was defined as replacement of greater than 70% of the mycotic nail bed and plate by normal and healthy appearing nail bed and plate, while any growth less than this was considered as treatment failure. Mycological cure was defined as negative microscopy under KOH examination and a negative culture in SDA at the end of the follow up period. At the end of the study, the results were compiled, tabulated and analyzed using suitable statistical tools like percentages and chi-square tests. [Table - 1]


  Results Top


In the itraconazole group (Group A), we observed fingernail involvement in 21.7%, toenail involvement in 30% and both fingernail and toenail involvement in 48.3% of the cases. In the terbinafine group (Group B), the corresponding figures were 26.7% for fingernail, 30% for toenail and 43.3% for both fingernail and toenail involvement. In either group, the maximum number of patients belonged to the age group 31-45 (45% in Group A and 47% in Group B). We observed associated dermatophyte infection of other sites in 19 (31.6%) patients (11, tinea pedis; 4, tinea manuum; 2, tinea cruris; and 2, tinea corporis) in Group A and in 15 (25%) patients (8, tinea corporis) in Group B. In both groups, the commonest associated dermatophyte infection was tinea pedis.

Microbiological study of the nail material by culture in SDA with chloramphenicol showed growth of dermatophytes, molds and yeasts. The commonest isolates in culture were dermatophytes, i.e. Trichophyton rubrum and Trichophyton mentagrophytes, seen in 60% and 65% of isolates in Groups A and B respectively. Yeasts ( Candida spp.) were seen in 23% of Group A and 18% of Group B isolates. Molds like aspergillus and scopulariopsis were observed in 17% of isolates of both Group A and Group B. [Table - 2]

During the course of the study, 10 (16%) patients in Group A and 12 (20%) patients in Group B could not complete the one-year follow up period and were excluded from the analysis of the results. Of the 50 patients in Group A, 41 (82%) showed clinical cure and 45 (90%) showed mycological cure at the end of one year's follow up. In Group B, of the 48 patients, clinical and mycological cure were observed in 38 (79%) and 42 (87%) patients respectively. The difference in cure rates between the two groups was not statistically significant (p> 0.05). Treatment failure was observed in 9 (18%) patients in Group A and 10 (21%) in Group B. No significant difference in the treatment failure rates was noticed between the two groups (χ2=0.074, p>0.05).

Clinical and mycological cure among the nondermatophyte mould in the itraconazole group was observed in 62% cases (5 out of 8) and in the terbinafine group in 44% (4 out of 9). For Candida species, itraconazole was more effective than terbinafine, 92% (12 out of 13) vs. 40% (4 out of 10). [Table - 3]

Adverse effects were seen in 9 (18%) patients on itraconazole (gastric upset, 4; taste disturbance, 3; headache, 1; and jaundice, 1) and in 11 (22%) in the terbinafine group (gastric upset, 5; headache, 2; maculopapular rash, 2; and altered taste, 2). None of these effects was significant enough to discontinue therapy except in one patient on itraconazole who developed jaundice in the middle of the third pulse. In this patient itraconazole was discontinued and other hepato-protective agents were given in consultation with the gastroenterology department. There was complete clearance of hyperbilirubinemia within a month and the hepatic enzymes reached normal levels at the end of another month. During the subsequent follow-ups the patient was perfectly healthy without any sequelae.

The cost of the 4-pulse regimen of terbinafine was Rs.2250 (approx.) and that of itraconazole was Rs.5600 (approx.).


  Discussion Top


Successful treatment of onychomycosis has been a challenge for dermatologists. Traditional agents like griseofulvin have a narrow spectrum, require a longer duration of therapy, and have a high relapse rate.[18],[21] Ketoconazole, although much more effective,[20],[21] carries risk of hepatotoxicity, that limits its widespread use. The agents most commonly used for the treatment of onychomycosis are fluconazole, itraconazole and terbinafine. These newer anti-fungal agents have better pharmacokinetic profiles, like prompt penetration of the nail and nail bed, persistence in the nail for months even after stopping therapy, and fewer adverse reactions.[9],[10],[14]

Itraconazole is a highly lipophilic triazole antimycotic. It has a spectrum of action against dermatophytes, yeasts, molds, dimorphic and dematiaceous fungi. It acts by inhibiting the enzyme 14-demethylase, a microsomal cytochrome P-450 enzyme in the fungal membrane (thus blocking the conversion of lanosterol to ergosterol, which is an important constituent of fungal cell membrane) leading to arrest of fungal growth. It reaches the distal end of the nail within two weeks of starting therapy and persists in the nail plate for 9-12 months. It is equally effective for the treatment of onychomycosis in the form of daily therapy as well as pulse therapy.

Terbinafine belongs to a newer family of antifungals, the allylamines. It acts by inhibiting the enzyme squalene epoxidase, blocking the biosynthesis of ergosterol. It is primarily effective against dermatophytes, and is less effective against yeasts, molds, and dimorphic fungi. Terbinafine reaches the nail plate by diffusion from both the matrix and the nail bed. It has been detected in the nail plate for 30-36 weeks after stopping therapy. Although conventionally given in a daily dose, pulse therapy with terbinafine for the treatment of onychomycosis is a viable option .Our study shows that pulse therapy with terbinafine 250 mg twice daily for 7 days a month is comparable to itraconazole pulse therapy of 200 mg twice daily and is significantly more cost effective for the treatment of onychomycosis. Both the agents achieved similar cure rates for dermatophytes, but itraconazole was more effective in nail infections caused by molds and candida. Both the agents were relatively free of major adverse effects when administered in the pulse dosage.


  Conclusion Top


Terbinafine pulse therapy is as effective as itraconazole pulse therapy in treating onychomycosis (due to dermatophytes? If the difference in the cure rates for non-dermatophytes was significant with itraconazole this needs to be mentioned in the concluding paragraph) but significantly cheaper, ensuring that patients are more likely to complete the therapy.



 
  References Top

1.Summerbell RC. Epidemiology and ecology of onychomycosis. Dermatology 1997;94:32-6.  Back to cited text no. 1      
2.Aly R. Ecology and epidemiology of dermatophyte infections. J Am Acad Dermatol 1994;31:21-5.  Back to cited text no. 2  [PUBMED]    
3.Fouilloux B. Onychomycosis and quality of life. Ann Dermatol Venerol 2003;130:1257-8.  Back to cited text no. 3  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
4.Lubeck DP. Measuring health-related quality of life in onychomycosis. J Am Acad Dermatol 1998;38:S64-8.  Back to cited text no. 4  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
5.Midgley G, Moore MK. Nail infections. Dermatol Clin 1996;14:41-9.  Back to cited text no. 5  [PUBMED]    
6.Andre J, Achten G. Onychomycosis. Int J Dermatol 1987;26:481-90.  Back to cited text no. 6  [PUBMED]    
7.Zaias N. Onychomycosis. Arch Dermatol 1972;105:263-74.  Back to cited text no. 7  [PUBMED]    
8.Epstein E. How often does oral treatment of toenail onychomycosis produce a disease-free nail? An analysis of published data. Arch Dermatol 1998;134:1551-4.  Back to cited text no. 8  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
9.Gupta AK, Scher RK, De Doncker P. Current management of onychomycosis. An overview. Dermatol Clin 1997;15:121-35.  Back to cited text no. 9  [PUBMED]    
10.Gupta AK, Lynde CW, Konnikov N. Single blind, randomized, prospective study of sequential itraconazole and terbinafine pulse compared with terbinafine pulse for toenail onychomycosis. J Am Ac Dermatol 2001;44:485-91.[Medline]  Back to cited text no. 10      
11.Arenas RJ. Dominguez-Cherit, Fernandez LM. Open randomized comparison of itraconazole versus terbinafine in onychomycosis. Int J Dermatol 1995;34:138-43.  Back to cited text no. 11      
12.De Doncker P, Decroix J, Pierard GE, Roelant D, Woesternborghs R, Jacqmin P, et al. Antifungal pulse therapy for onychomycosis: a pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic investigation of monthly cycles of 1-week pulse therapy with itraconazole. Arch Dermatol 1996;132:34-41.  Back to cited text no. 12      
13.Tosti A, Piraccini BM, Stinchi C, Venturo N, Bardazzi F, Colombo MD. Treatment of dermatophyte nail infections: an open randomized study comparing intermittent terbinafine therapy with continuous terbinafine treatment and intermittent itraconazole therapy. J Am Acad Dermatol 1996;34:595-600.  Back to cited text no. 13  [PUBMED]    
14.Scher RK. Diseases of the nails. In : H. Conn (editor), Current therapy. WB Saunders Co: Philadelphia; 1990. p. 736-42.  Back to cited text no. 14      
15.Nolting S, Brautigam M, Weidinger G. Terbinafine in onychomycosis with involvement by non-dermatophytic fungi. Br J Dermatol 1994;130:16-21.  Back to cited text no. 15  [PUBMED]    
16.Matthieu LP, De Doncker, Cauwenbergh G, Woestenborghs R, van de Velde, Janssen PA, et al. Itraconazole penetrates the nail via the nail matrix and the nail bed: an investigation in onychomycosis. Clin Exp Dermatol 1991;16:374-6.  Back to cited text no. 16      
17.Willemsen M, De Doncker P, Willems J, Woestenborghs R, Van de Velde V, Heykants J, et al. Post-treatment itraconazole levels in the nail: new implications for treatment in onychomycosis. J Am Acad Dermatol 1992;26:731-5.  Back to cited text no. 17  [PUBMED]    
18.Roberts DT. Oral therapeutic agents in fungal nail disease. J Am Acad Dermatol 1994;31:78-81.  Back to cited text no. 18  [PUBMED]    
19.Nahass GT, Sisto M. Onychomycosis: successful treatment with once weekly fluconazole. Dermatology 1993;186:59-61.  Back to cited text no. 19  [PUBMED]    
20.Galimberti R, Negroni R, Iglesia de Elias Costa MR, et al. The activity of ketoconazole in the treatment of onychomycosis. Rev Infect Dis 1980;2:596-8.  Back to cited text no. 20  [PUBMED]    
21.Faergemann J, Anderson C, Hersle K, Hradil E, Nordin P, Kaaman T, et al. Double-blind, parallel-group comparison of terbinafine and griseofulvin in the treatment of toenail onychomycosis. J Am Acad Dermatol 1995;32:750-3.  Back to cited text no. 21  [PUBMED]    



 
 
    Tables

  [Table - 1], [Table - 2], [Table - 3]

This article has been cited by
1 Efficacy and safety of 1064-nm Nd:YAG laser in treatment of onychomycosis
Rungsima Wanitphakdeedecha,Kanchalit Thanomkitti,Sumanas Bunyaratavej,Woraphong Manuskiatti
Journal of Dermatological Treatment. 2016; 27(1): 75
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
2 British Association of Dermatologistsæ guidelines for the management of onychomycosis 2014
M. Ameen,J.T. Lear,V. Madan,M.F. Mohd Mustapa,M. Richardson
British Journal of Dermatology. 2014; 171(5): 937
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
3 Therapies for the treatment of onychomycosis
Aditya K. Gupta,Maryse Paquet,Fiona C. Simpson
Clinics in Dermatology. 2013; 31(5): 544
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
4 Oral Therapy for Onychomycosis: An Evidence-Based Review
Daniel Coelho Sá,Ana Paula Botto Lamas,Antonella Tosti
American Journal of Clinical Dermatology. 2013;
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
5 Recent updates in oral terbinafine: its use in onychomycosis and tinea capitis in the US : Terbinafine use in onychomycosis and tinea capitis
Lauren Van Duyn Graham, Boni E. Elewski
Mycoses. 2011; : no
[VIEW] | [DOI]
6 Antifungal agents for onychomycoses. | [Antifú ngicos disponiblesparaeltratamientodelasmicosisungueales]
Carrillo-Muñoz, A.J., Tur-Tur, C., Hernández-Molina, J.M., Santos, P., Cárdenes, D., Giusiano, G.
Revista Iberoamericana de Micologia. 2010; 27(2): 49-56
[Pubmed]
7 Antifúngicos disponibles para el tratamiento de las micosis ungueales
Alfonso Javier Carrillo-Muñoz,Cristina Tur-Tur,Juan Manuel Hernández-Molina,Patricia Santos,Delia Cárdenes,Gustavo Giusiano
Revista Iberoamericana de Micología. 2010; 27(2): 49
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
8 The significance of itraconazole for treatment of fungal infections of skin, nails and mucous membranes
Hans Christian Korting,Claudia Schöllmann
Journal der Deutschen Dermatologischen Gesellschaft. 2009; 7(1): 11
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
9 Update on terbinafine with a focus on dermatophytoses
Newland, J.G., Abdel-Rahman, S.M.
Clinical, Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology. 2009; 2: 49-63
[Pubmed]
10 The significance of itraconazole for treatment of fungal infections of skin, nails and mucous membranes | [Stellenwert von itraconazol in der behandlung von pilzinfektionen der haut, nägel und schleimhäute]
Korting, H.C., Schöllmann, C.
JDDG - Journal of the German Society of Dermatology. 2009; 7(1): 11-20
[Pubmed]
11 Successful treatment of proximal white subungual onychomycosis with oral terbinafine therapy
Aman, S., Nadeem, M., Haroon, T.S.
Journal of the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan. 2008; 18(11): 728-729
[Pubmed]
12 Current Management of Onychomycosis
Nunley, K.S., Cornelius, L.
Journal of Hand Surgery. 2008; 33(7): 1211-1214
[Pubmed]
13 Current Management of Onychomycosis
Kara S. Nunley,Lynn Cornelius
The Journal of Hand Surgery. 2008; 33(7): 1211
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
14 An open randomized comparative study to test the efficacy and safety of oral terbinafine pulse as a monotherapy and in combination with topical ciclopirox olamine 8% or topical amorolfine hydrochloride 5% in the treatment of onychomycosis
Jaiswal, A., Sharma, R., Garg, A.
Indian Journal of Dermatology, Venereology and Leprology. 2007; 73(6): 393-396
[Pubmed]
15 The Safety of Oral Antifungal Treatments for Superficial Dermatophytosis and Onychomycosis: A Meta-analysis
Chia-Hsuin Chang, Yinong Young-Xu, Tobias Kurth, John E. Orav, Arnold K. Chan
The American Journal of Medicine. 2007; 120(9): 791
[VIEW] | [DOI]
16 Toenail onychomycosis: Current and future treatment options
Finch JJ, Warshaw EM
Dermatologic Therapy. 2007; 20(1): 31-46
[Pubmed]



 

Top
Print this article  Email this article
Previous article Next article

    

Online since 15th March '04
Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow